, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

All cases which raise significant issues of principle are of course included, as well as those raising new issues about the competence or procedures of the Ombudsman, and those which contain findings of general interest. For those who wish to study all cases closed after an inquiry, the website has provided this information in a fresh and comprehensive form since July 1998 by publishing all decisions in English and in the language of the complainant. A paper copy of any decision may also be obtained from the Ombudsman's office.

RESULTS

When the 1997 Annual Report was dealt with by the European Parliament, certain critical voices suggested that the Ombudsman had success in only a small percentage of cases. This view was reached on the basis of all received complaints, including those which are outside the mandate. I do not believe that this way of judging the results of an Ombudsman's activities is really fair. There is not much that can be done about a complaint which is outside the mandate, other than to try to advise the complainant or to transfer the complaint to a competent body. We have managed to do this in almost 80 % of such cases.

During 1998, the Ombudsman's office handled a total of 1617 cases. Of these, 1372 were new complaints received in 1998. One own-initiative inquiry was launched during the year, and 185 inquiries were closed with a reasoned decision. In 45 % of these cases, either the institution settled the matter, a friendly solution was found, or the case was closed with a critical remark. In 1997 and 1996, the equivalent figures were 40 % and 35 % respectively. During 1998, in 52 % of cases, no maladministration was found. A finding of no maladministration is not always negative for the citizen. The process of inquiry requires that the institution explain to the complainant what it has done and why. In some cases, it even convinces the complainant that it has acted properly.