, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

"1. to ensure a healthy financial management and restore a financial balance in the pension fund which according to a report by Coopers and Lybrand of 4 August 1992 was deficient at that moment;

2.

to allow the accountants to carry out reliable actuarial calculations necessary within the framework of financial management, and to allow the budgetary authorities to make more detailed budgetary forecasts;

3.

not to discriminate against the members who had joined the scheme at its very beginning and whose financial situation would in fact be less favourable than the 'new members' who would be able to make back payments."

The complainants' observations

In their observations the complainants maintained their complaints.

The Decision

1.

The allegation that the deadline for joining the pension scheme was not properly advertised

1.1. It appears that there are no regulatory rules governing the question of what should be considered to be proper advertisement to MEPs. In particular, the European Parliament's Rules of Procedure do not contain any relevant rules.

1.2. In relation to Article 173 of the Treaty and Articles 90 and 91 of the Staff Regulations, the Community Courts have ruled that the notification of a measure normally occurs when the measure is communicated to the addressee and he is able to take knowledge of it(11). The Courts have also ruled that the burden of proof of due notification lies with the administration. However, this case-law does not appear to be transposable to this case. The case-law concerns individual acts which adversely affect the addressee, where the exact definition of the moment of notification is of utmost importance for the calculation of the time limit within which judicial proceedings can be brought. This case concerns communication of general information concerning an offer, of which the addressee can choose to make use or not. In case the addressee applies and his application is refused, it is that refusal to which the time limit for bringing judicial proceedings applies(12).

1.3. As for the Community institutions' administrative practices, it appears that frequent use is made of general communications to make possible rights known to servants for which they may have to apply(13).