, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

Therefore, the Ombudsman found that the fact that the Parliament had not provided for a general possibility for joining the scheme with retroactive effect did not constitute an instance of maladministration.

2.3. As concerned the question whether the time limit for joining the scheme in the complainants' case should have been waived, the examination of this question fell into various parts. Firstly it had to be examined whether the refusal to waive the time limit was unfair and subsequently whether it was discriminatory.

2.4. As for the fairness, it shall firstly be observed that the Regulation governing the pension scheme does not contain any provision allowing for waiving the time limit on grounds of equity. The relevant provision of the Regulation simply provides that Members shall have a "maximum period of six months following their election or re-election" for joining the scheme.

2.5. In the absence of an explicit provision allowing for waiving the time limit, the question was whether under Community law there exists a general principle to the effect that a time limit shall be waived on grounds of equity. There appears to be no such general principle.

2.6. Against this background and taking into account the reasons of sound financial management indicated by the Parliament, it could not be considered unfair that the time limit was applied strictly to the complainants.

2.7. As for the allegation about discrimination, it shall be recalled that the principle of equal treatment requires that identical situations are treated identically and that different situations are not treated identically.

2.8. It was put forward that another MEP was allowed to join the scheme in spite of being outside the time limit. It appeared from the Parliament's opinion that this Member, prior to the introduction of the time limit, received assurances that she could join the scheme. Thus, her situation was not identical to the one in this case.