, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

In her observations, Ms S. pointed out that the system adopted by the Commission for the selection procedure of candidates was very unclear. The complainant was still unsatisfied with the Commission's reply which, in her opinion, was too general.

Further inquiries

Since some important aspects of the complaint were not sufficiently dealt with in the Commission's opinion, the Ombudsman requested further details of the new selection procedure. Moreover, in order to review the correctness of the selection procedure for trainees in which Ms S. had participated, the Ombudsman requested some further elements, such as the applications of the selected Spanish candidates.

In reply, the Commission explained that the new selection procedure involved the creation of pre-selection groups of Commission officials for each nationality. These groups were a mixture of Commission staff with experience in personnel and recruitment matters, as well as recently recruited civil servants. Their task is to screen applications on the basis of the criteria laid down in the applicable rules, and the preferences indicated by the candidates.

The Ombudsman forwarded the documents submitted by the Commission related to the new selection process to the complainant with an invitation to comment on the initiatives taken by the institution. There was no reply to this letter.

The Commission's reply also included a number of confidential documents to be inspected by the Ombudsman, namely the applications of the candidates chosen in the October 1996 training period. These documents had been used by the Commission as the basis for its final selection.

The Decision

On the basis of Articles 15 and 16 of the rules governing in-service training with the Commission of the European Communities (Decision of the Commission of 16 March 1976), applicants are to be selected on the basis of the qualifications obtained during their studies, provided that an appropriate geographical balance is maintained. Priority in the selection process is to be given to applicants who have undertaken studies in, or have some professional knowledge of, European integration.

Because of the nature of this selection procedure, the appointing authority enjoys a margin of discretion. In using its discretion, the Commission has to consider the merits of the candidates as set out in the above rules.