, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

In her observations, X. stated that she had decided not to appeal to the Court of First Instance.

She claimed that the bill from the medical centre was correctly filled out and stated that the price of the treatment had been calculated on a package basis, from which medical costs could not be separately identified. She considered that the Parliament's refusal to reimburse her showed lack of flexibility and good will.

X.

also commented on the procedure followed by the Ombudsman in dealing with complaints. She considered that it was not appropriate to begin the procedure by forwarding the complaint to the institution concerned for an opinion.

The Decision

1.

Powers of the European Ombudsman to make inquiries into the case

1.1. The European Parliament stated that the normal procedure in a case of this type would be to make an application to the Court of First Instance.

1.2. Within the constitutional framework of the Treaties, the Court of Justice is the highest authority on the interpretation and application of Community law. However, the Ombudsman makes inquiries to help uncover instances of maladministration in the activities of Community institutions and bodies.

1.3. To be admissible, a complaint to the Ombudsman must have been preceded by the appropriate administrative approaches to the institution concerned. Similarly, if the complaint concerns work relationships between the Community institutions and bodies and their officials and other servants, no complaint can be made to the Ombudsman unless all the possibilities for the submission of internal administrative requests and complaints, in particular the procedures referred to in Article 90(1) and (2) of the Staff Regulations, have been exhausted by the person concerned(10).

1.4. Once these internal procedures have been exhausted, Community officials or other servants have the possibility either to appeal to the Court of First Instance, or alternatively, to complain to the Ombudsman.

2.

The Ombudsman's procedures

2.1. In her observations, the complainant considered that it was not appropriate for the Ombudsman to begin an inquiry by forwarding the complaint to the institution concerned for an opinion.

2.2. Article 3(1) of the Statute of the Ombudsman, requires that the Ombudsman shall inform the institution or body concerned of his inquiries into any suspected instance of maladministration, so that they can submit any useful comment to him.

3.

Medical considerations on the type of cure to be followed