2.9. Secondly, it was put forward that Parliament under the retirement pension scheme - the scheme in Annex III - had waived the time limit in one case, i.e. the case mentioned in the letter of 24 July 1995 quoted above. In this regard, it shall be noticed that the demand concerned was presented one month after the expiration of the time limit concerned, that it was presented under another scheme in a different financial situation and that the demand concerned entitlement to a pension to which the Member concerned had already contributed. Furthermore, it appeared from the amendment to the rules, for which the administration was requested to submit a proposal in the quoted minutes of the meeting of the College of Questors, that demands presented outside time limit have no retroactive effect. The situation thus appeared to be different from the one in this case.
2.10. Consequently, the principle of equal treatment did not appear to have been violated. However, the question whether the principle of equal treatment had been violated is a question of law and therefore, it shall be recalled that the Court of Justice is the highest authority on questions of Community law.
On the basis of the European Ombudsman's inquiries into this complaint, there appeared to have been no maladministration by the European Parliament. The Ombudsman therefore closed the case.
3.1.2. THE COUNCIL OF THE EUROPEAN UNION
INSPECTION TO CHECK REASONS FOR REFUSAL OF ACCESS TO DOCUMENTS
Decision on complaint 1087/10.12.96/Statewatch/UK/IJH against the Council
The complaint
The complaint concerns four requests for documents which the complainant addressed to the Council in July and August 1996. His applications were made under the Council Decision on public access to Council documents(15) (hereafter "Decision 93/731/EC").
On 30 July 1996, he requested copies of 71 reports considered at meetings of the "K4" Committee held in September, October and November 1994. On 31 July 1996 he requested six documents dating from 1992 and 1993. On 13 August 1996 he sent two letters to the Council. The first requested a copy of a single report produced in 1992. The second requested copies of 26 reports considered at the JHA Council held in Luxembourg on 4 June 1996, 23 of which had been produced in 1996 and three of which bore earlier dates.