As for the complainant's grievance concerning VAT, it appeared that he considered that Danish VAT rules on imported second-hand cars were discriminatory to Danish dealers like him. He stated that the Danish rules imply that a private person residing in Denmark can import a second-hand car from Germany without paying VAT in Denmark, if VAT has been paid in Germany on the profit margin of the dealer. On the other hand, the Danish dealer who imports the same car will have to pay Danish VAT on the full price of the same car and can get the German residual VAT reimbursed. The consequence is that the price that the Danish dealer can offer the private person on the same car will be significantly higher than the price the German dealer can offer. Therefore the complainant considered that the rules led to a discriminatory distortion of competition and were contrary to Directive 94/5/EC concerning VAT on second-hand goods, the fundamental principle of which is that VAT shall be paid on the dealer's profit margin.
Mr H. addressed the Commission on this question, and as he was not satisfied with the Commission's initial response, he had his lawyer and a Danish Member of the European Parliament pursue the matter vis-à-vis the Commission. In its answer to the lawyer of 3 March 1995 as well as in its answer of 23 October 1995 to the MEP, the Commission maintained that the Danish rules were not contrary to the Community Directives in this field. In his letter of 23 October 1995 the Commissioner responsible stated:
"You (your MEP) point out the distortions of competition that seem to exist against the Danish dealers of second-hand cars because of the different regimes applicable in Denmark and Germany.
At this stage of the harmonisation of national laws, I am afraid there is no way, in legal terms, to cope with that inconvenience. As a matter of fact, Article 28o(2) of Directive 94/5/EC concerning special arrangements applicable inter alia to second-hand goods, expressly allows Denmark to derogate from the margin scheme.
Should you however still have comments or new information, please do not hesitate to contact the services of DG XXI - unit 01."