2.2. The Commission observed that a first acknowledgment receipt had been sent for the letter dated 6 September 1995 and a second acknowledgment receipt for the two other letters. It also indicated that, upon receipt of the allegations, the UCLAF Directorate immediately started to investigate the information received from the complainant. But the Commission concluded that the mission and the tasks of the UCLAF Directorate did not permit a disclosure of information concerning the actions it had undertaken.
2.3. The Ombudsman noted that the information which the Commission obtained in the context of investigations into fraud with regard to operations financed by the Structural Funds is covered by professional confidentiality. Reference can be made, in particular, to Article 10 of the UCLAF Regulation(34), which deals with the exchange of information between the Member States and the Commission. This provision foresees that Member States and the Commission shall take all necessary precautions to ensure that the information which they exchange remains confidential. Article 10(2) stipulates that this information may not be sent to persons other than those in the Member States or within the Community institutions whose duties require that they have access to it.
2.4. It appeared from the above provision that the UCLAF Directorate was entitled not to disclose the results of its investigations to the complainant, because of the requirements of its mission and tasks. It appeared to the Ombudsman that providing information to third parties about ongoing Commission investigations into alleged fraud in a Member State and the results thereof might jeopardise ongoing investigations of the UCLAF Directorate.
2.5. For those reasons, the fact that the UCLAF Directorate, in its response to the complainant, informed only in general terms about the ongoing investigations and gave no details concerning its inquiries into the alleged mismanagement of the funds did not constitute an instance of maladministration.
The alleged failure of UCLAF to act on the complainant's allegations