Thus, the Ombudsman cannot inquire into infringements allegedly committed by the car manufacturers and importers, but only into the Commission's investigations of those infringements.
Furthermore, Article 2(2) of the Statute provides: "Any citizen of the Union (...) may (...) refer a complaint to the Ombudsman in respect of an instance of maladministration ...".
As stated in the European Ombudsman's report for 1995, this means that is it not the task of the Ombudsman to examine the merits of legislative acts of the Communities such as Regulations and Directives. Thus, the Ombudsman could not deal with Mr R.'s allegation concerning the merits of Regulation (EC) No 1475/95.
The Commission's alleged passivity and the adopted course of action
Firstly, it was necessary to recall the legal framework within which Mr R.'s complaint was to be assessed.
As for the substantive law, Article 85(1) of the Treaty prohibits anti-competitive agreements and behaviour which can affect trade between the Member States. Article 85(3) provides that under certain circumstances, Article 85(1) can be declared inapplicable. Under Council Regulation (EEC) No 19/65, the Commission is empowered to make such a declaration of inapplicability by means of a general Regulation, a so-called exemption Regulation. The effect of such a general Regulation is thus that agreements that meet the conditions laid down by the Regulation, are not prohibited by Article 85(1) of the Treaty. On the contrary, if an agreement does not meet the conditions or violates these, it is in principle caught by the prohibition in Article 85(1). As concerns the motor vehicle sector, the Commission has, under Regulation (EEC) No 19/65, adopted Regulation (EC) No 1475/95 on the application of Article 85(3) of the Treaty to certain categories of motor vehicle distribution and servicing agreements. Article 6 of Regulation (EC) No 1475/95 entails that it does not apply where a manufacturer, the supplier or another undertaking directly or indirectly seeks to restrict the freedom of final consumers to obtain a new motor vehicle from whichever authorised dealer they choose within the Community. Thus, such a behaviour is in principle prohibited by Article 85(1) of the Treaty.