In order to ensure that the exercise of the Commission's discretion in this process had followed principles of good administration, the Ombudsman inspected the applications of the successful Spanish candidates for the October 1996 training period. In view of the high professional experience and good qualifications of all the selected candidates, the Ombudsman considered that there was no instance of maladministration.
As regards the general criteria employed by the Commission services for the vetting of candidates, the Ombudsman noted that the institution had implemented a new procedure to ensure a more efficient and objective selection.
On the basis of the Ombudsman's inquiries into this complaint, there appeared to have been no maladministration by the Commission. The Ombudsman therefore closed the case.
FRAUD INVOLVING THE EUROPEAN SOCIAL FUND: ALLEGED FAILURE TO ACT BY UCLAF
Decision on complaint 943/14.10.96/Open Line/GR/BB/OV against the European Commission
The complaint
In October 1996, Mr I. complained to the Ombudsman against the Commission's anti-fraud unit UCLAF, alleging lack or refusal of information relating to allegations of fraud in the administration of European Social Fund (ESF) programmes in Greece. Mr I. complained on behalf of a Greek initiative group which has its seat in Athens.
Between September 1995 and June 1996 the complainant wrote three letters to the UCLAF Directorate alleging irregularities in the management of ESF resources in Greece from between 1994 to 1996. He asked for immediate action by the Community authorities. In reply to his first letter, he received a standard reply from the UCLAF Directorate, thanking him for his interest and stating in general terms that investigations would be carried out.
Mr I. wrote a second letter to UCLAF providing additional detailed information. This letter received no reply. Mr I. therefore sent a third letter to UCLAF in which he repeated the information in the second letter and added new information concerning the alleged irregularities. In reply to this third letter, the complainant received a new standard letter from the UCLAF Directorate dated 7 August 1996 stating that it was investigating the case and would take the appropriate measures.
In his complaint to the Ombudsman, Mr I. asked the Ombudsman to put an end to the alleged mismanagement of ESF activities in Greece. He also complained that his letters had not received an adequate response.
The inquiry
The Commission's opinion