, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

The limitations laid down on the hearing of witnesses are unacceptable because, if understood literally, they could even oblige a witness to lie (for example to cover up a fraud case) if instructed to do so by superiors in the administration. To make a reliable inquiry possible, witnesses should only be required to speak the truth and release all relevant facts during an inquiry. The reasoning behind the present provision in the Statute is in fact an obstacle to dealing properly with cases of corruption and fraud within the European administration. If the aim is that the Ombudsman's inquiries should contribute to fighting possible corruption and fraud in the administration on the basis of complaints or initiatives, these inappropriate limitations should be removed.

In practice, the Ombudsman has not yet been refused access to a file, although conversations and disputes have arisen due to the abovementioned limitation. The process of taking testimony has not so far been initiated. To avoid doubt, it would be better for the Treaty to make clear that the Ombudsman has full access, for the purposes of his inquiries, to the files and documents held by Community institutions and bodies and that officials must give full and truthful testimony to the Ombudsman. Naturally, the requirement in Article 4(1) of the Statute that the Ombudsman and his staff must not disclose documents or reveal information obtained in the course of inquiries should remain in force.

FRUITFUL COOPERATION

The Rules of the European Parliament concerning the European Ombudsman have recently been renewed and are almost up to date. It seems necessary however to insert a provision concerning how Parliament deals with the Annual Report and with possible special reports of the Ombudsman, in order to ensure that the main responsibilities in this respect be conferred on one responsible committee within the Parliament, which when appropriate could request expert opinions from other committees depending on the substance of the report. There is already a draft report ready about this issue and most likely the matter will be settled before the end of this legislature, which would mean that all the needed procedures will have been established when the new Parliament takes over in the second half of 1999.