, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999
5.

Thus, in summary, the Commission has to act upon a complaint lodged by a person having a legitimate interest. It may find that the complaint shall be dismissed on the grounds that it lacks sufficient "Community interest" and shall then inform the complainant in a so-called Article 6 letter. This letter puts to an end a possible failure to act on the complaint. The complainant may submit observations on the Article 6 letter, maintaining the complaint. If the Commission persists in its view that the complaint lacks "Community interest", it shall adopt a final stand to that effect. When assessing the "Community interest", the Commission shall act within the limits of its legal authority. The Commission's final stand may be challenged by the complainant.

6.

Hereafter, Mr R.'s complaint could be assessed.

7.

It is common ground that over some years, Mr R. brought suspected infringements to the Commission's attention. It appeared that the Commission considered that Mr R. qualified as a person with a legitimate interest in lodging complaints within the meaning of Article 3(2) of Regulation No 17.

It appeared that one of the alleged infringements was resolved pursuant to the Commission's intervention and that the other ones were investigated.

8.

During the investigations, the Commission addressed the abovementioned letter of 1996 to Mr R., in which it referred to cases of personal interest. This letter appeared to be in line with the Commission's general policy as it is among others described in the abovementioned quote from its annual report on competition policy, which in turn rests upon the case-law of the Community Courts. The claim that it constitutes maladministration did therefore not appear warranted.

9.

The investigations initiated in some of Mr R.'s complaints were still on-going. For the time being, there were no elements at hand indicating that the Commission should not be investigating these complaints with due care, in accordance with principles of good administration.

  • celex=31995R1475