, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

On 29 March 1995, Mr F. received an invitation to participate in a restricted tender. He sent an offer to the Commission, for which he received an acknowledgement on 15 May 1995. Mr F. stated that the elaboration of his offer had involved considerable costs as well as extensive cooperation with no less than 13 companies in eight Member States.

By letter of 15 February 1996, Mr F. was informed that the selection procedure had been unfruitful, but the standard letter did not give any reasons for this.

On 26 August 1996, Mr F. asked DG I of the Commission for the reasons for the closure of the procedure. In its reply of 28 October 1996, the Commission stated that the procedure was closed because none of the bids complied with the tender requirements.

Mr F. complained to the Ombudsman that:

(i)

the reasons which he was eventually given were insufficient;

(ii)

his expenses should be reimbursed by the Commission.

The inquiry

The Commission's opinion

In relation to the relevant points, the Commission stated the following:

The complainant was informed on 15 February 1996 that the selection board had examined all offers received and that it had decided to close the procedure because it was unsuccessful.

Annex II, Article 8 of the description of the services provides that according to the provisions for tenders in non-public procedures the Commission is not obliged to offer a contract at the end of the tender procedure. The Commission is neither obliged to reimburse unsuccessful participants in the procedure when it decides not to offer any contracts. (Annex III, No 7).

The complainant's observations

In summary, the complainant made the following main points:

The Commission is not obliged to award contracts. In view of careful public spending, the sudden interruption of the procedure does however not seem logical. There were 157 bidders of 1570 enterprises and 16560 experts involved. The interruption after the assessment of the bids appeared to cause avoidable economic damage. The action of the selection board became even less understandable as the Commission had afterwards decided to offer contracts in a direct negotiation procedure.

The Decision