, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

In order to weigh up the legal implications of this request, it is necessary to start out from the European Union's undertaking to make the workings of the Community institutions and bodies more transparent and more open to the public. This commitment was spelt out in the Final Act of the Treaty on European Union, which includes Declaration No 17 on the right of access to information. Similarly, it was reaffirmed in a number of European Councils, such as those at Birmingham and Edinburgh.

At present, there are only rules to foster greater public access to information as regards access to documents. In relation to the Commission, this institution adopted on 2 June 1993 communication 93/C 166/04 on transparency in the Community(19), and, on the basis of the guidelines set out in that text, on 8 February 1994 it adopted Decision 94/90/ECSC/EC/Euratom on public access to Commission documents(20). In the absence of more general rules concerning general information, existing rules on access to documents could provide an appropriate surrogate to decide on citizen's requests for information sent to the institutions.

2.

Conflict between transparency and privacy rights

The Commission has stated in its comments that specific information on the salaries and other emoluments, mainly travel allowances, concerning individual members of the Commission could impinge on their privacy rights. Accordingly the information which this institution has made public in this case referred only to the entire Commission.

Public release of information could come into conflict with other important values, such as the right of privacy. In the context of the Commission Decision on public access to Commission documents, protection of the individual or privacy is considered a mandatory exception which bars the disclosure of the requested document by the institution. In interpreting this provision, the Court of First Instance has stated that: "[...] the Commission is obliged to refuse access to a document falling under any one of the exceptions contained in this category once the relevant circumstances are shown to exist"(21). In view of the circumstances of the case, the European Ombudsman does not consider that the Commission violated principles of good administration when it disclosed only information related to the whole of the Commission.

3.

Failure to answer correspondence

  • celex=31993D0731
  • celex=31967R0422
  • celex=31994D0090