, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

The Commission acknowledged that there was a failure to deal promptly with the request for information sent by the complainant to its Madrid office. However, the institution has offered an explanation for the long delay and apologised for it. Since a reply has also been given, there were no grounds for the European Ombudsman to pursue this aspect of the case further.

4.

Control of public expenditure

In the complainant's view, the failure of the Commission to respond to her questions on the salaries and other emoluments of two Commissioners, made evident the lack of control on this type of expenditure.

All Community accounts, including its personnel and functioning expenditures, are periodically audited by the Court of Auditors. As established in Article 188c of the Treaty, this institution "shall examine whether all revenue has been received and all expenditure incurred in a lawful and regular manner and whether the financial management has been sound".

The European Ombudsman, noted that there were no indications in the 1993 and 1994 Reports by the Court of Auditors(22) that irregularities might have taken place as regards salaries or other allowances received during those periods by the members of the Commission.

In view of these findings, there appeared to be no maladministration and the Ombudsman therefore closed the case.

DANISH TAXATION ON IMPORTED SECOND-HAND CARS

Decision on complaint 764/9.7.96/TH/DK/PD against the European Commission

The complaint

Mr H., a Danish citizen lodged a complaint with the European Ombudsman in July 1996 concerning the Commission's dealing with and assessment of a complaint that he had lodged with the Commission, alleging that Denmark had failed to fulfil its obligations under Community law.

In his complaint Mr H. stated that for years he had been corresponding with the Commission concerning the calculation of VAT on second-hand cars imported to Denmark from another Member State (hereinafter just: imported second-hand cars). He put forward that the answers that he had received from the Commission were untrue. From the Annexes to the complaint it appeared that this correspondence also related to Danish registration fees on imported second-hand cars. Consequently, the Ombudsman asked the Commission to address both questions when giving its comments on the complaint.