, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

Having been re-elected to the European Parliament in 1994, Mr M. was allowed to join for the period 1994 to 1999, but not for the previous period. As Mr B. was no longer an MEP, he could not apply to join for the period 1994 to 1999, and he was not allowed to join for the previous period.

Mr M. contacted different instances within the Parliament with a view to being allowed to join the scheme retroactively, for the period before 1994. He argued that he had not been informed about the time limit introduced in 1992 and that Parliament had applied the time limit in an unfair and discriminatory way. On 24 July 1995, the Chairman of the Pension Fund set up under the scheme, who was also Member of the College of Quaestors of the Parliament, replied. The letter drew Mr M's attention to the cut-off date for joining the scheme, and informed him that the possibility of backdated contributions had been considered. It had been concluded, however, that such backdating was neither practical nor legal. The letter added: "May I also correct an error you have made concerning the College of Quaestors' discussion on 24 April concerning Mr L. As you will see from the enclosed extract of the minutes of that meeting that matter concerned the French and Italian pension schemes administered by the European Parliament on behalf of the French and Italian Governments. Thus it refers to Annex III of the Rules on Members' Expenses and Allowances rather than Annex X (now Annex IX) which actually contains the rules of MEPs' additional voluntary pension scheme. In addition to this, the request by Mr L. was to receive a pension from, rather than join, that particular pension scheme."

The abovementioned extract of the minutes of the meeting of the College of Quaestors read:

"... under the rules governing the pensions for Members of the French National Assembly, which applied by analogy to French Members of the European Parliament, applications to receive a pension must be made in writing within six months of the date on which a Member or former Member becomes eligible. A former French Member, who was unaware of this provision, had made his application to the European Parliament seven months after becoming eligible. After a brief discussion, the College:

authorised an exception to the current Rules in favour of Mr L. in order to enable him to receive the pension notwithstanding his failure to apply within the six-month time limit;

  • celex=31974D0097