However, it appeared that the letter only concerned four of the files which the Commission had opened pursuant to his complaints. Following Mr R.'s observations, the Commission was to reach a final conclusion whether to close those four files. Furthermore, it appeared that the Commission was still investigating two other files that it had opened pursuant to Mr R.'s complaints.
Other facts
It shall be recalled that the Commission publishes a yearly report on competition policy. In its report for 1996, the Commission stated in paragraphs 54 to 55, concerning the car sector that it received numerous complaints from consumers who experience major problems in buying a car outside their Member State.
In accordance with normal practice, the European Parliament adopted a resolution on the Commission's report, in which it: "deplores the lack of a genuine internal market relating to the distribution and servicing of motor vehicles, as numerous complaints from consumers prove; calls on the Commission to ensure once and for all a free market where consumers can without any problems buy a car outside their own Member State and where no obstacles to parallel trade exist."(28)
Furthermore, it shall be noted that in January 1998, the Commission adopted a Decision(29) establishing infringement of the competition rules, committed by Volkswagen and imposing a fine of ECU 102 million on the company. In the press release that the Commission issued, when adopting the decision, it was stated:
"Commenting on the Decision, Mr Van Miert said that the Commission would not hesitate to take the necessary measures against motor manufacturers who did not comply with the Regulation (EC) No 1475/95 governing motor trade ...
The size of the fine is an indication that the Commission will not tolerate practices of this kind and will act with similar determination against other manufacturers who set out to partition the market."
The Decision
The Ombudsman's competence
In his observations, Mr R. asked the Ombudsman to investigate directly the car manufacturers and car importers concerned and to scrutinise the merits of Regulation (EC) No 1475/95. According to Article 2(1) of the Statute of the Ombudsman: "Within the framework of the Treaties (...) the Ombudsman shall help to uncover maladministration in the activities of the Community institutions and bodies (...). No action by any other authority or person may be subject of a complaint to the Ombudsman."