As for the complainant's grievance concerning VAT, it appeared that the Commission had dealt with it and assessed it. The crucial question was thus equally whether the Commission's assessment was right. It appeared to be established and uncontested between Mr H. and the Commission that the rules in question could lead to a competitive disadvantage in certain situations between Danish dealers and German dealers. Furthermore, there appeared to be agreement between Mr H. and the Commission that the Danish rules were allowed under Directive 94/5/EC. The question was thus whether the regime allowed under Directive 94/5/EC was contrary to the Treaty. The Commission had found that the said disadvantages stemmed from the differences in the rate of VAT which are allowed under Community law as it stands. It appeared that the disadvantages would in fact disappear if the same VAT rate was applicable in Germany and Denmark. The Commission's assessment therefore appeared to be right. However, it shall be recalled that the Court of Justice is the highest authority on questions of Community law.
On the basis of the European Ombudsman's inquiries into this complaint, there appeared to have been no maladministration by the European Commission. The Ombudsman therefore decided to close the case.
TENDERING PROCEDURE FOR SUPPLY OF TECHNICAL SERVICES TO THE COMMISSION
Decision on complaint 817/19.8.96/0KA/NL-EN/IJH against the European Commission
The complaint
In August 1996, Dr. O. d. K complained to the Ombudsman about a call for tenders organised by the Commission. His consultancy company submitted a tender to supply technical assistance to the Directorate for Public Health and Health and Safety at Work (DG V F). The Commission then informed him that it had cancelled the call for tenders because of translation errors in the tender documents and that it intended to proceed with a new limited accelerated procedure. He participated unsuccessfully in the new procedure.
He claimed that the Commission had violated procedural requirements of the Services Directive(24) by failing to:
supply documents for the second tender by the most rapid means, as required by Article 20(3) of the Directive;
respond to his faxed requests for clarifications within four days of the closing date for tenders, as required by Article 20(2) of the Directive;
respond to his request for negotiations, as foreseen by Article 11(2) of the Directive.
He also claimed: