, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

As for the complainant's other grievance concerning registration fees, the background was, in summary, the following: By judgment of 11 December 1990 in Case C-47/88 (ECR I-4509), the Court of Justice ruled on the question whether Danish registration fees for imported second-hand cars amounted to discriminatory taxation, prohibited by Article 95 of the EC Treaty. The Danish tax system implied that imported second-hand cars were subject to a motor vehicle registration fee of 90 % of their value as new cars, while second-hand cars originating in Denmark were not subject to a registration fee. In order to justify this, Denmark argued that, as it has no car industry, all second-hand cars originating in Denmark had, at a certain moment, been imported as new cars. New cars were submitted to a registration fee of 105 % of their price, including VAT, up to the price of DKK 19750,00 and 180 % of the rest of the price. Thus, a considerable part of the price of second-hand cars originating in Denmark would consist of a residual registration fee. Consequently, registration fees for imported second-hand cars should be fixed at a level to take account of the residual registration fee in second-hand cars originating in Denmark. Although the Court of Justice accepted this consideration in principle, it found that generally, the Danish system led to a manifestly excessive taxation of imported second-hand cars. The system was therefore contrary to Article 95 of the EC Treaty. After the Court's ruling, the Danish authorities established a system which in principle aims at ensuring that imported second-hand cars are not submitted to registration fees to a further extent so that the total value of the car will equal the value of an identical second-hand car originating in Denmark. The system is administered so that before the import of a second-hand car, the importer, whether private or professional, can obtain a provisional indication of what the registration fee will be. After import, the authorities fix the final registration fee to be paid, possibly after inspecting the imported second-hand car.