On 20 June 1997 the Council complied with the Ombudsman's request. As regards the application of a "fair solution", the Council remarked that its opinion on another complaint by the same complainant (1053/25.11.96/Statewatch/UK/IJH) also applied in this case.
The complainant's observations
In his observations, the complainant claimed that:
the Council was not entitled to apply a "fair solution" to his four requests for documents,
the Council is not entitled to refuse access to documents on the grounds that they have been recently adopted, or that they include the views of Member States.
The Ombudsman's inspection of documents
The Ombudsman considered it necessary to inspect the seven documents to which the Council had refused access under Article 4(2) of Decision 93/731/EC.
The Ombudsman informed the complainant of the inspection which, in conformity with Article 4(1) of the Statute of the Ombudsman, could not involve release to the complainant of the documents themselves, or any information contained in them.
The inspection was carried out in the Justus Lipsius building of the Council in Brussels on 2 October 1998. As well as providing access to the documents, the Council services offered to supply copies to the Ombudsman's services if required. After inspection of the documents, the Ombudsman's services considered that it was unnecessary to take copies.
The Decision
The jurisdictional point
1.1. The Council's objection to the Ombudsman's competence appeared to be based on two propositions:
the competence of the Ombudsman does not extend to actions taken by the Council in relation to cooperation in the fields of Justice and Home Affairs (the "third pillar"); and
the subject matter of the complaints concerns action taken by the Council under the third pillar.
1.2. The Ombudsman's decision that he can deal with the complaints is based on his view that the second of these propositions is mistaken. It is therefore unnecessary for him to take a position on the first proposition.
1.3. The subject matter of the complaints concerns the Council's response to requests for access to documents. The requests were made under Decision 93/731/EC and were dealt with by the Council accordingly. Decision 93/731/EC was made under Article 151 of the EC Treaty. In its judgement in Netherlands v Council(16), the Court of Justice confirmed that the Decision has legal effects vis-à-vis third parties as a matter of Community law.