, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

In his observations Mr H. maintained that the Commission had not dealt with his case. Furthermore, as for his grievance related to registration fees, he put forward that in some cases the Danish authorities' establishment of the final fee varied considerably from the provisional fee and that the staff in charge of the evaluation of imported second-hand cars was not competent. He furthermore stated that before importing a second-hand car, one was required to produce the registration papers of the car in order to know the provisional fee and that this requirement implied in practice that one had to buy the car without knowing the amount of the final fee, the reason being that no car dealer would hand out registration papers without first having sold the car in question. He furthermore stated that the Danish rules entailed a problem in the leasing of imported second-hand cars and that imported second-hand taxis were not put on an equal footing with second-hand taxis originating in Denmark. Furthermore, he stated and evidenced that a person resident in Denmark who worked for a German company in Germany could not fully use the company car in Denmark that the company put at his disposal.

The Decision

As for both grievances, it has to be recalled that the European Ombudsman cannot inquire into the activities of national authorities. The Ombudsman can therefore only inquire into Mr H.'s original allegation that the Commission had not dealt with and properly assessed the case that he had brought forward.

As for his grievance concerning registration fees, it appeared that the Commission had dealt with it and assessed it. The outstanding question was thus whether the Commission's assessment was right. The system that the Danish authorities set up after the abovementioned ruling of the Court of Justice, was aimed at ensuring that the registration fees were set so that the total value of the imported second-hand car, including registration fee, did not exceed that of a second-hand car originating in Denmark, including the residual registration fee paid when the car was new. The Commission found that this system as such complied with the Court's ruling. If Mr H. had proof of the contrary, the Commission invited him to submit that proof. There were no elements at hand which indicated that this assessment was wrong. However, it shall be recalled that the Court of Justice is the highest authority on questions of Community law.

  • celex=31994L0005