On 26 September 1996, the Council's General Secretariat replied to the complainant. The reply stated that his requests "in this regard are repeat applications which equally relate to a very large number of documents" and that the General Secretariat had found a fair solution under Article 3(2) of Decision 93/731/EEC by considering only the documents produced in 1996 (i.e. 23 of the 26 documents requested in the second letter dated 13 August 1996). The General Secretariat provided the complainant with 16 of the 23 documents, but denied access to the seven others.
On 10 October 1996, the complainant made a confirmatory application for all the documents to which he had been refused access. On 20 November 1996, the Presidency of the Council replied upholding the original decision to apply a "fair solution" and therefore considering only the seven documents produced in 1996.
In relation to these seven documents, the Council stated that it had carefully balanced the complainant's interest in seeking access against the interest of the Council in keeping its deliberations confidential and that the latter interest outweighed the former. It gave further details as follows:
"Documents 7574/96, 6982/2/96 and 7753/96 contain detailed national positions on a Convention on external frontiers, on a recommendation on illegal employment of third-country nationals and on a Convention of extradition, respectively. These issues are still under discussion or have been adopted only very recently.
Documents 7717/1/96 and 7718/1/96 contain detailed national positions on the budget of the Europol Drugs Unit and the Europol computer system.
Finally, documents 7788/96 and 7791/96 contain references to opinions of the Council Legal Services on the issue of judicial interpretation of the Europol Convention, as well as comments made by some delegations on this matter."
In his complaint to the Ombudsman, the complainant claimed that the Council's treatment of his requests for access to documents was unfair and possibly unlawful.
The inquiry
The Council's opinion
The complaint was forwarded to the Council, together with five other complaints made by the same complainant. In March 1997, the Council sent a reply which contested the competence of the Ombudsman to deal with the complaints. On 15 April 1997, the Ombudsman wrote to the Council confirming his original decision that the complaints were within his mandate and renewing his request for an opinion on the substance of the complaints.