, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

3.2. The complainant claims that, in applying Article 4(2), the Council is not entitled to refuse access to documents on the grounds that they have been recently adopted, or that they include the views of Member States. The Ombudsman is not aware of any legal rule or principle which would require the Council, when balancing the interests under Article 4(2), to exclude either of these elements from consideration.

3.3. The Ombudsman's inspection of documents confirmed that the contents of the documents in question correspond to the reasons given by the Council.

3.4. There appears, therefore, to be no maladministration by the Council in relation to this aspect of the case.

Conclusion

As regards the application by the Council of a "fair solution", the Ombudsman's critical remark in 1053/25.11.96/Statewatch/UK/IJH (decision of 28 July 1998) applies also to the complainant's requests for documents in the present case.

As regards the refusal of access to seven documents under Article 4(2) of Decision 93/731/EC, on the basis of the Ombudsman's inquiries, there appears to be no maladministration by the Council.

The Ombudsman therefore closed the case.

3.1.3. THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION

COMPETITION: REPLY TO A SUBMISSION - OMBUDSMAN'S COMPETENCE

Decision on complaint 449/96/20.02.96/HKC/PD against the European Commission

The complaint

In February 1996, HKC, a Danish law firm, complained to the Ombudsman on behalf of LF, a Danish trade union. The complaint concerned the Commission's decision to grant an exemption from the competition rules for an alliance agreement between two airlines, whose employees were members of LF. In the complainant's view, the agreement would lead to job losses amongst LF members. According to LF, the Commission had an obligation to take effects on unemployment into account when considering whether to grant competition exemptions. The complaint also concerned the fact that LF's observations, which the Commission had invited LF to submit to it under the applicable exemption Regulation, were neither acknowledged nor replied to.

The inquiry

The Commission's opinion