, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

A common type of complaint concerns failure to reply to correspondence. Soon after the beginning of the Ombudsman's activity, it became clear that a telephone call from the Ombudsman's office to the responsible service often results in an immediate reply to the citizen. In such cases, there is normally no point pursuing the inquiry further.

The former practice of the Ombudsman in cases in which his intervention succeeded in obtaining a reply to unanswered correspondence was to inform the complainant that there no longer appeared to be grounds to conduct an inquiry into the complaint under Article 138e of the EC Treaty (see section 2.5). For statistical purposes, such cases were included in the category "no grounds for inquiry" in both the 1996 and 1997 Annual Reports. In March 1998, this practice was reviewed, following a query from Mr Edward Newman (rapporteur for the Committee on Petitions' report on the 1997 Annual Report) about the cases classified as "no grounds for inquiry". It was concluded that, in future, such cases should be classified as "settled by the institution". There were 32 decisions of this kind in 1998.

Complaints about unanswered correspondence: examples of cases settled by the institution

On 3 March 1998, Mr B. complained to the Ombudsman that the Commission had failed to reply to his letter of 2 December 1996 in which he asked for information about the introduction of the euro. The Ombudsman contacted the responsible service of the Commission to request that they reply to the complainant and send him the information which he had requested. Further to this intervention, the Commission replied to the complainant on 18 March 1998. Since this step appeared adequate to settle the matter, the Ombudsman closed the case.

(Case 269/98/ADB)

In June 1998, Ms V. complained on behalf of the County Administrative Court of Uusimaa that the Office for Official Publications of the European Communities (OPOCE) had failed to reply to two letters. The Court had written to OPOCE in Finnish on 10 June 1996 to inquire why it had not received the 1994 Special Edition of the Official Journal of the European Communities. A reminder letter was sent on 14 April 1997 in English. No reply was received to either letter.