, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

According to the complainant, cars produced by German manufacturers are often more expensive in Germany than in some other Member States, for example Denmark, the Netherlands and Finland. Given this fact, some consumers living in Germany address car dealers in other Member States in order to buy their car there. When they do so, they sometimes run into problems such as for example refusal to sell to consumers resident in Germany, excessive delivery times or artificially increased prices.

On a number of occasions, Mr R., who lives in Germany, addressed individual car dealers in other Member States, with a view to buying a car. It appeared that he met with some problems of the kind mentioned. Considering that refusals or reluctance to sell cars to consumers on the grounds that they live in another Member State are contrary to the Community competition rules, Mr R. addressed the Commission. Subsequently, there was considerable correspondence between him and the Commission, from which it appeared that the Commission did not in principle contest the complainant's perception of law that the reported instances were contrary to the competition rules, including Commission Regulation (EC) No 1475/95(27). However, Mr R. considered that the Commission had not taken steps to enforce the competition rules. He expressed in particular discontent with a letter that the Commission had addressed to him on 28 June 1996. In the letter, the Commission referred to the exchange of correspondence between Mr R. and the Commission and sought to explain its policy on the matter. The relevant paragraphs read as follows:

"... The Commission, as the responsible administrative authority acting in the public interest, is required to ensure compliance with EC competition policy and, when infringements occur, take the requisite organisational measures and, in particular, determine priorities. In making that choice the Commission gives precedence to those cases which are particularly significant from the political, economic or legal point of view. This principle also applies, of course, to the receipt and handling of complaints. In this connection I must point out, however, that the European competition rules do not enable the Commission to help private persons to enforce their subjective rights. This is basically the function of national courts which - unlike the Commission - are also able to determine entitlement to damages ...