The complaint was forwarded to the Commission. In its opinion, the Commission claimed that the Ombudsman was not competent to take a stand on the question of whether effects on unemployment should be taken into account when a competition exemption was granted, as the matter concerned an alleged failure in applying the law, as opposed to maladministration. The Commission furthermore contended that it was not obliged to reply to observations which it had invited third parties, such as LF, to submit, as the observations were merely intended to assist the Commission in its analysis.
The complainant's observations
In its observations, the complainant maintained the complaint and considered the Ombudsman competent to deal with all its aspects.
The Decision
The Ombudsman considered that he was competent to deal with the question of whether the Commission was obliged to take effects on unemployment into account when considering whether to grant competition exemptions. Further remarks on this issue were made in a letter to the President of the Commission, the contents of which are summarised in the section on further remarks below.
On the substantive issue the Ombudsman found that, on the basis of the applicable rules and the case-law of the Court of Justice, there appeared to be no obligation upon the Commission to take such considerations into account.
As for the Commission's failure to acknowledge and reply to LF's observations, the Ombudsman observed that the applicable Regulation contained no such obligation. However, by inviting third parties to submit observations, intended to assist it in its analysis, the Commission had placed itself in a situation where the citizens could reasonably expect a reaction from it: all the more so in this case, as LF had an interest in the decision by virtue of the fact that its members were possibly affected by it. The Commission's failure to give a reaction to LF had been, therefore, an instance of maladministration.
Given that this aspect of the case concerned procedures relating to specific events in the past, it was not appropriate to pursue a friendly settlement of the matter. The Ombudsman therefore closed the case.
Further remarks
In a letter to the President of the Commission, which accompanied the Decision, the Ombudsman made, in summary, the following further remarks: