He also suggested that the Commission's answer would have to be reviewed in the light of the European Union's commitment towards transparency and public access to information. In view of those principles, he proposed that a satisfactory solution could be found if the Commission, after balancing the interests at stake, were to provide some clearer and more precise information, thereby justifying a clear conclusion as to the information which could be made available.
In its reply, the Commission indicated that it had tried to strike a balance between the need for transparency and the protection of privacy. In order to reach this compromise, it had disclosed information on salaries and other allowances related to the whole of the Commission rather than that concerning specifically two of its members.
Then, the Commission stated that its members' monthly salaries plus other allowances were last established by the Council on December 1996, and explained how they were calculated. As regards representation expenses, they were reimbursed after the invoice had been issued. They were reimbursed up to a maximum of ECU 11347 per year (for the Commissioner responsible for foreign affairs, the sum is ECU 17023). Officials who have to travel, in compliance with their duties, receive a reimbursement for travel expenses and daily subsistence allowances which are related to the country in which the mission takes place.
The reply of the Commission was forwarded to the complainant with an invitation to consider the solution proposed by the Commission. In the reply, the complainant expressed her satisfaction with the efforts undertaken by the European Ombudsman to find a friendly settlement of this matter. Nevertheless, she still believed that the reply of the Commission had not answered her questions clearly and specifically. In her view, the control of public expenditure is a paramount objective which should take precedence over any privacy right.
The Decision
Right to the Community's information
The requests for information sent by the complainant to the Commission in her letters of 17 October and 17 December 1995 raise questions relating to the right of all Community citizens to be informed on important aspects of the administrative workings of the Commission.