, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999
5.

in the case of complaints concerning work relationships between the institutions and bodies and their officials and servants, the possibilities for submission of internal administrative requests and complaints must have been exhausted before lodging the complaint (Article 2(8)).

An example of inadmissibility of a complaint because of Court proceedings

In February 1998, Mr S., a lawyer, wrote to the Ombudsman concerning legal proceedings begun by a client company PO. PO had complained to the Commission in March 1997 about a proposed merger between two other companies. The Commission refused to open an examination of the merger. PO brought proceedings in the Court of First Instance to challenge the refusal.

Mr S. requested that the Ombudsman:

(i)

intervene in the proceedings before the Court of First Instance;

(ii)

examine whether the Commission had acted fairly in refusing to investigate PO's complaint.

In relation to the first request, Article 1(3) of the Statute of the Ombudsman provides that "The Ombudsman may not intervene in cases before courts ...".

In relation to the second request, Article 138e of the EC Treaty provides for the Ombudsman to conduct inquiries: "except where the alleged facts are or have been the subject of legal proceedings."

The Ombudsman therefore informed Mr S. that he could not intervene in the proceedings before the Court of First Instance, nor inquire into the question of whether the Commission may have acted unfairly in dealing with PO's complaint.

(Case 223/98/IJH)

2.5. GROUNDS FOR INQUIRIES

The Ombudsman can deal with complaints that are within his mandate and which meet the criteria of admissibility. Article 138e of the EC Treaty provides for him to "conduct inquiries for which he finds grounds". In some cases, there may not be sufficient grounds for the Ombudsman to begin an inquiry, even though the complaint is technically admissible. Where a complaint has already been dealt with as a petition by the Committee on Petitions of the European Parliament the Ombudsman normally considers that there are no grounds for him to open an inquiry, unless new evidence is presented.

An example of a complaint that provided no grounds for an inquiry