, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999
(v)

As for the correspondence with the cabinet of Commissioner Matutes, there could have been a misunderstanding in the letter of 24 February 1994 between two firms with identical names ("C."), one located in Spain and the other in France. The latter had obtained some Community funding. The misunderstanding was created by the fact that the President and Director-General of the French company "C." was also a business partner of the complainant. The Commission had written to Mr P. apologising for the confusion.

(vi)

The Commission denied that there had been deficiencies in the application of Regulation (EEC) No 3904/92, which had been monitored by both its own financial services and the Court of Auditors.

The complainant's observations

In summary, Mr P. made the following observations:

(i)

Although Regulation (EEC) No 3904/92 was published on 31 December 1992, the Commission communicated with him for the first time only 22 days before the deadline of 31 March 1993 for the presentation of proposals.

(ii)

As regards the failure to reply to the request for further information of December 1994, the complainant indicated that he did not understand the aim of such a request since a decision had been taken in February 1994 and his project had already been excluded.

(iii)

As for the sum requested, when he submitted his application he had no information about the total amount of European Community funds to be granted to Spain within this particular programme.

(iv)

The Commission should have disclosed the name of the customs agents whose projects had been selected.

The Decision

1.

Allegedly deficient measures adopted by the Commission

1.1. The allegedly deficient response by the Community to the situation of customs and commission agents following the entry into force of the internal market, had already been the subject-matter of several complaints addressed to the European Ombudsman(36).

1.2. Articles 7b and 7c of the Treaty required a number of actions to be taken by the Commission and the Council to ensure a balanced progress of all sectors affected by the entry into force of the internal market. Although the Commission considered that assistance for the sector was primarily a responsibility of the Member States, it undertook several initiatives contained in a 1992 vade-mecum on the restructuring of the customs sector. Specific measures of assistance were also contained in Regulation (EEC) No 3904/92.