, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

1.3. It is not the task of the Ombudsman to examine the merits of legislative acts or legislative proposals of the Communities. This type of judgment goes beyond the boundaries of maladministration, and instead concerns considerations of a political nature. In this context, it should be recalled that the European Parliament has adopted several very critical resolutions on this matter, such as those of 17 September and 20 November 1992 as well as the Jackson Report of 4 November 1992.

2.

Project selection

2.1. The complainant criticised the selection of the projects made jointly by the Commission and the Spanish Agencia Tributaria, and the exclusion of his project from the 20 finally selected. In his view, the time period for the submission of proposals had been unduly short; and the request for further information at a late stage of the selection procedure had been inappropriate.

2.2. Although the complainant only received information about the possibilities of Community assistance on 8 March 1993, the contents of the programme and its time schedule were set out in Regulation (EEC) No 3904/92 which was published in the Official Journal of the European Communities of 31 December 1992. A reasonable amount of time had therefore been given for the presentation of projects. Consequently, there appeared to be no grounds to justify the claim of an unduly short deadline.

2.3. The Commission justified the exclusion of the complainant's project on the grounds of its vagueness and its excessive financial request. The complainant had not responded to a request for further information since he believed that the decision had already been taken in February 1994.

2.4. In assessing the relevant factors to be taken into account for the purpose of deciding to award a contract following an invitation to third parties, Community institutions enjoy a large degree of discretion(37). That discretion cannot justify, however, any misuse of powers or serious and manifest errors in the selection procedure(38).

2.5. From the information available to the Ombudsman, there appeared to be no evidence to suggest that the Commission did not act within the limits of its legal authority in adopting its decision on the applications for assistance to be funded under Regulation (EEC) No 3904/92. There was therefore no evidence of maladministration in relation to this aspect of the case.

3.

Allegedly misleading information from the Commission's services