1.4. The Decision was interpreted and applied by the Court of First Instance in Carvel and Guardian Newspapers v Council(17), a case which also involved access to third pillar documents. Given the limitations on the jurisdiction of the Court of Justice imposed by Article L of the Treaty on European Union, the Court of First Instance would have had no jurisdiction to deal with this aspect of the Carvel case if access to third pillar documents was itself a third pillar matter.
1.5. From the above, it appears that the correct interpretation and application of Decision 93/731/EC on public access to documents is a matter of Community law and not a third pillar matter, even if the documents in question concern actions under the third pillar. The Ombudsman informed the Council of this decision on 15 April 1997. (NB: In its judgment of 17 June 1998, the Court of First Instance rejected, on similar grounds, the Council's objection to the jurisdiction of the Court in the Tidningen Journalisten case(18)).
The application of a "fair solution"
2.1. The complainant has claimed that Article 3(2) of Decision 93/731/EC does not entitle the Council to apply a "fair solution" to his four applications for documents.
2.2. As the Council noted in its opinion, the issue in relation to this aspect of the complaint is identical to that raised in another complaint by the same complainant: 1053/25.11.96/Statewatch/UK/IJH. The Ombudsman's decision of 28 July 1998 in the above case therefore also applies to the present case.
2.3. Applying the above decision, in particular as regards the meaning of the terms "repeat applications" and "very large documents", it is clear that the Council was not entitled to apply a "fair solution" under Article 3(2) of Decision 93/731/EC to the four requests for documents in this case.
The refusal of access under Article 4(2)
3.1. The Council refused access to seven documents under Article 4(2) of Decision 93/731/EC, which reads as follows: "Access to a Council document may be refused in order to protect the confidentiality of the Council's proceedings."
According to the established case-law, the application of this provision requires the Council to strike a genuine balance between, on the one hand, the interest of the citizen in obtaining access to documents and, on the other, any interest of its own in maintaining the confidentiality of its deliberations.