An analysis of complaints outside the mandate but concerning Community law, made by José Martínez Aragón, Principal Legal Advisor in my Secretariat, and presented in Chapter 2 of this Annual Report, shows that many such complaints concern the right to freedom of movement within the Union. Freedom of movement is one of the rights of Union citizenship guaranteed by Article 8a of the Treaty. Would it not be appropriate for the European Ombudsman to be able to assist the European citizens, in order that they benefit from this fundamental right conferred upon them?
To me it seems totally proper to believe in the principle of subsidiarity and to try consistently to promote the idea that national ombudsmen and similar bodies be encouraged and assisted in dealing with complaints from European citizens concerning Community law. This will be even more relevant when the Treaty of Amsterdam enters into force, bringing questions of visa, asylum and foreigners' rights, which are classic complaints issues for ombudsmen and similar bodies at a national level, into the domain of Community law. The right to petition the European Parliament should also be made better known, especially in matters of principle or with more political significance.
As our cooperation with the national and regional bodies has been developing so positively, I am not prepared to propose any change at this point concerning the mandate of the European Ombudsman as laid down in the Treaty, but undertake to increase my efforts in this field.
What really could help the citizen would be that all remedies under Community law be clearly mentioned in the Treaty, in order properly to inform the European citizens of their rights in this respect. In a society governed by the rule of law, the courts constitute the main system through which the rule of law is upheld. At the moment, however, there is no provision which informs the citizen of the vital role played by national courts in ensuring respect for Community law. Furthermore, the right to complain to national ombudsmen and to petition parliaments in cases of conflicts with the administration involving Community law should also be mentioned in the Treaty. Each Member State should have an obligation to ensure that its legal structure includes an effective and appropriate non-judicial body to which citizens may apply for this purpose.