, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

The complaint was forwarded to the Commission. In its opinion, the Commission first observed that a first and later a second acknowledgment receipt had been sent to the complainant and that the information received from the complainant had immediately been examined within the UCLAF Directorate. The Commission further stated that, in November 1995, its services asked the Greek authorities for information concerning the ESF projects in which irregularities had been alleged. The Greek authorities provided this information in March 1996.

On the basis of this information, the Commission carried out an on-the-spot investigation from 29 to 31 October 1996, which also took account of the additional information forwarded by the complainant. A visit to one of organisations named by the complainant was organised in order to evaluate the role of this body in the management and the follow-up of ESF projects and to check the allegations made by the complainant.

The investigation revealed some non-eligible expenditures for the projects checked. The national authorities agreed with the results of this investigation and promised to proceed to the necessary corrections and to extend their control to all the programmes of the beneficiary concerned.

The Commission further observed that its services carried out a series of controls in Greece during the years 1995 to 1996 with, as a result, the rejection of the totality of the certifications of the Greek centres for professional training (KEK) and a demand to reform the Greek certification system.

On basis of the above information the Commission concluded that it had not been inactive further to the information received from the complainant, but that the mission and the tasks of the UCLAF Directorate did not permit a disclosure of details of its activities.

The complainant's observations

In his observations, the complainant stated that the Commission had not taken into account all his allegations and that its conclusions were incomplete. More particularly, the complainant observed that the audit carried out by the UCLAF Directorate had failed to examine all the cases for which he had made allegations. He enclosed a memorandum concerning all his allegations.

The Decision

1.

Request to the Ombudsman to put an end to the alleged mismanagement of ESF funds