, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

The abovementioned Regulation contains a detailed description of the procedure, and indicates that the duty on an imported used car is based on its real value. On the basis of the information provided, the Commission is of the view that this is not a duty that in general is higher than what corresponds to the residual value of the duty involved in the value of a used car of the same type and age registered in Denmark when new. The basis for assessing a vehicle is the normal price of a similar vehicle or a vehicle that, so far as possible, is a similar make and model in a normal state of repair at the time of registration. Deductions are made or extra charges added for mileage, state of repair, improvements and other characteristics. The final price may thus differ from the various trade lists depending on the individual assessment. The estimated dutiable value of used cars may not lead to deviations from the list prices officially applied to cars originally registered in Denmark if it is proved that they are identical in all respects.

If you find that the dutiable value finally established is too high compared with the residual dutiable value for similar vehicles registered for the first time in Denmark, I urge you to contact my department again with details of the assessment."

As Mr H. was not satisfied by either answer from the Commission, he lodged the complaint with the Ombudsman, alleging that the Commission's answers were untrue and contrary to Community law.

The inquiry

The Commission's opinion

In its comments the Commission put forward that it had dealt appropriately with Mr H.'s case and it maintained its analysis of the case, set out in the letters quoted above. Furthermore, it stated that it was still studying Mr H.'s allegation that the Danish rules, although in compliance with Article 28o of Directive 94/5/EC, were contrary to Article 95. The Commission stated that this argument concerning a Directive's incompatibility with the EC Treaty raised problems that it would have to analyse in detail. By letter of 26 June 1997 the Commission informed the Ombudsman about the results of its analysis. It stated: