On the basis of the Ombudsman's inquiries into this complaint, there appeared to have been no maladministration by the Commission. The Ombudsman therefore closed the case.
DEADLINE FOR THE PRESENTATION OF PROPOSALS IN A CALL FOR TENDERS
Decision on complaint 1101/16.12.96/CFUI/IT/JMA against the European Commission
The complaint
In December 1996, the Association CFUI complained to the Ombudsman concerning the short deadline for the submission of proposals in a call for tenders.
The Commission published a notice on 29 October 1996(39) inviting the presentation of proposals to be funded through the European Social Fund (ESF) concerning innovatory actions for the creation of jobs. Submission of applications in 1996 had to be postmarked by 30 November 1996.
Because of the usual delay in the post, CFUI received the Official Journal of the European Communities only on 15 November 1996. It immediately requested the necessary application forms from the Commission services (DG V).
Since the documents had not arrived by 26 November 1996, CFUI asked the Commission to send the forms by fax. This was done on 27 November 1996. However, CFUI was unable to submit an application to the Commission in due time.
In its complaint, CFUI claimed that the time limit was too short, and that it appeared that not all the potential tenderers had received the application forms at the same time.
The inquiry
The Commission's opinion
The complaint was forwarded to the Commission. In its opinion, the Commission explained the different steps involved in the selection procedure of this call for tenders, and its timetable, as well as the exchanges with the complainant.
As regards the launching of this initiative, since the process required the agreement of the ESF Committee, the first step could only be taken after the meeting of the committee at the end of September 1996. Thereafter, the Commission had to conclude its internal consultations before any proposal could appear in the Official Journal of the European Communities. As a result, the call for tenders was published only on 29 October 1996.
As for the setting of the deadline for the submissions of proposals, the Commission stated that because of budgetary reasons, it was imperative to have the process concluded by the end of 1996. Because the evaluation of proposals would take several weeks, the Commission services fixed 30 November 1996 as the deadline.