, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

The Commission also indicated that the only request for application forms which it had received from the complainant was the fax dated 26 November 1996. The Commission also pointed out that its services had replied expeditiously to this fax.

The Ombudsman forwarded the Commission's opinion to the complainant with an invitation to make observations. No reply was received.

The Decision

In accordance with Article 102 of the Regulation which implements the Financial Regulation, the deadline for the submission of tenders "shall be fixed according to the nature of the contract and shall be dependent on the length of time necessary for the preparation of the reply to the invitation to tender"(40).

On 29 October 1996, the Commission published a deadline for the submissions of proposals of 30 November 1996. In its opinion, the Commission gave several reasons for the short time limit, in particular: the need to consult the ESF Committee at the end of September 1996; the length of the subsequent internal Commission procedures and the need to commit expenditure before the end of 1996. This reasoning did not appear to contradict the criteria laid down in the above Regulation.

The Ombudsman stated in a previous case (complaint 154/02.10.95/SF/IT) that where a short deadline is established for the submission of applications, it is a good administrative practice to consider whether the postal services alone are an adequate means of communication to inform interested parties.

In the context of that case, the Commission had acknowledged that, in the future, deadlines should be longer and that, if this was not possible, telefax ought to be used as a complementary means of communication. This procedure was used in the present case.

On the basis of the Ombudsman's inquiries into this complaint, there appeared to have been no maladministration by the Commission. The Ombudsman therefore closed the case.

PROTECTION AGAINST FOREST FIRES: INTERPRETATION OF REGULATION (EEC) No 3529/86

Decision on complaint 26/97/VK against the European Commission

The complaint

In January 1997, Mr L. complained to the Ombudsman that the Commission had failed to ensure that Italian authorities comply with the Regulation on protection of the Community's forests against fire(41).