, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

As regards the factual situation, the Commission confirmed the position as described by the complainant. However, it considered that no infringement of Community law had occurred. Since none of the documents forwarded in the complainant's letters proved that Mr K. still held Finnish nationality, the Commission considered the approach taken by the Portuguese Supreme Court was justified. Furthermore the Commission stated that, until now, it had not used infringement proceedings under Article 169 of the Treaty against any ruling rendered by a national court.

The Ombudsman forwarded the Commission's comments to the complainant with an invitation to make observations. No observations were received.

The Decision

1.

Failure to answer correspondence

1.1. The Commission acknowledged that there was a failure to deal promptly with the letters sent by the complainant. It offered an explanation and apologised for the delay.

1.2. In view of these facts, it appeared that there were no grounds for the European Ombudsman to pursue further this aspect of the case.

2.

Decision not to take up a complaint

2.1. Under Article 155 of the Treaty, the Commission's duty as the "guardian of the Treaty" is to ensure that Community law is applied.

2.2. In carrying out its duty as guardian of the Treaty, the Commission investigates possible infringements of Community law which come to its attention as a result of complaints, or at its own initiative. The investigation may lead to the sending of a letter of formal notice to the Member State concerned, which has the opportunity to submit its observations. If the Commission then considers that the Member State has failed to fulfill an obligation under the Treaty, Article 169 provides for it to deliver a reasoned opinion on the matter.

2.3. If the Commission chooses not to pursue an inquiry into the matter, there must be some reasoning supporting such course of action. Those reasons should provide the basis for any potential inquiry by the European Ombudsman in order to ensure that no maladministration has taken place.

2.4. The Commission justified its inaction in this case on the grounds that the approach taken by the Portuguese Supreme Court was justified because none of the documents forwarded by the complainant proved that his client still held Finnish nationality.

The Commission also pointed out that until now it had not used infringement proceedings under Article 169 of the Treaty against any ruling rendered by a national court.