, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

Decision on complaint 176/97/JMA against the European Commission

The complaint

In February 1997, Mr D. complained to the Ombudsman on behalf of his client, Mr K. The complaint concerned the Commission's failure to reply to letters which he had addressed to it on 7 August 1996 and 11 December 1996.

These letters had been sent to the Commission as formal complaints against alleged infringements of Community law by the Portuguese authorities.

In his first letter to the Commission, the complainant explained that his client Mr K., originally a national of Finland, had been arrested by the Portuguese authorities following an extradition request from the Finnish authorities. However, in the course of the legal process, it was revealed that Mr K. had also taken the nationality of the Dominican Republic. The competent Portuguese judicial authorities considered that, by taking the nationality of the Dominican Republic, Mr K. had lost his original Finnish nationality, and accordingly applied the rules concerning third country nationals, rather than those for European Union citizens. This approach was confirmed by the Portuguese Supreme Court. The complainant considered that this legal interpretation breached Article 8 and 8A of the Treaty. Furthermore he claimed that the Portuguese Supreme Court had a duty to refer the matter to Court of Justice for a preliminary ruling, in accordance with Article 177 of the Treaty.

Mr D. therefore asked the Commission to intervene, in its role of guardian of the Treaty, to ensure that the Portuguese authorities properly applied Community law.

In his second letter to the Commission of 11 December 1996, Mr D. provided additional documentation to his complaint.

The inquiry

The Commission's opinion

The complaint was forwarded to the Commission. In its opinion, the Commission stated that it was only after a thorough evaluation of the documents submitted in the complainant's letters that the Commission was able to draft a reply in June 1997. The Commission recognised the long delay, and apologised for not having replied to the letters in a more reasonable time.