If the Commission chooses not to pursue an inquiry into the matter, there must be some reasoning supporting this course of action. Those reasons should provide the basis for any potential inquiry by the Ombudsman in order to ensure that no maladministration has taken place.
The Commission justified its inaction in Mr P.'s case on the grounds that the assessment of the complaint was dependent on the interpretation of Portuguese law and that the facts in dispute were already the object of two legal proceedings before the national courts.
National courts could handle cases involving the incorrect application of Community law in an expeditious way, and the preliminary reference procedure of Article 177 allows for questions of Community law to be referred to the Court of Justice.
In reviewing the course of action chosen by the Commission, the Ombudsman found that the institution had acted within the limits of its legal authority and therefore that no instance of maladministration had been established.
Prompt reply to letters from complainants
The Commission stated in its opinion that Mr P.'s complaint to the Commission had been registered as such. However, Mr P. was never informed in writing of the registration.
As the Ombudsman has stated in similar cases, the Commission as a public administration has the duty properly to reply to the queries of citizens. By not doing so in the present case, the Commission had not abided by principles of good administrative behaviour(45).
The European Ombudsman noted, however, that the Commission had recognised this failure and apologised to the complainant. No further remark by the Ombudsman therefore appeared to be necessary.
On the basis of the inquiries of the European Ombudsman into this complaint, it appeared that the Commission chose not to take any action against a Member State following the complaint sent by Mr P., taking into account that the assessment of the complaint was dependent on the interpretation of Portuguese law, and also that the facts in dispute were already the object of two legal proceedings before the national courts. In reviewing the course of action chosen by the Commission, the European Ombudsman found that the institution had acted within the limits of its legal authority and therefore no instance of maladministration was established.
The Ombudsman therefore closed the case.
REFUSAL BY A NATIONAL COURT TO REQUEST A PRELIMINARY RULING: COMMISSION'S DECISION NOT TO PURSUE A RELATED COMPLAINT