, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

The complaint was forwarded to the Commission. As regards the reasoning of the rejection decision, the Commission observed that, given the limited financial resources (ECU 17 million for use in around 100 countries), a strict selection procedure was necessary, and that the projects selected were those which were likely to have the maximum impact on strengthening democracy, the rule of law and respect for human rights in the country. The Commission further stated that the present project was dealt with under the same procedure and in the same objective manner as the others. The Commission also considered that the reasons given for the rejection decision were not contradictory, given that it first informed the complainant that the project did not fulfil the selection criteria for the budget heading and later informed him that the main obstacle was that only projects which contributed to the democratic development of the country could be funded.

With regard to the failure to reply to the complainant's correspondence asking for explanations, the Commission stated that the periods for answering the complainant (three weeks for the letter of 8 April 1997 and eight weeks for the letter of 12 November 1997) were reasonable considering the workload and the human resources available.

The complainant's observations

The complainant observed that the Commission ignored the approval of the project by the Angolan Government. As regards more particularly the reasoning of the rejection decision, the complainant stated that the Commission never informed him of the exact selection criteria and why his project did not fulfil those criteria. Therefore the complainant asked the Ombudsman to continue his investigation.

As regards the failure to reply, the complainant observed that the Commission's reply of 8 April 1997 was in fact an answer to the letter of 6 March 1997 which was already a reminder of the letter of 27 December 1996. Therefore the observation of the Commission that it replied within three weeks was not correct.

Further inquiries

After careful consideration of the Commission's opinion and the complainant's observations, it appeared that further inquiries were necessary, more particularly in order to determine which selection criteria for the funding under budget heading B7-7 0 2 0 had not been fulfilled by the complainant.