The Commission observed that the complainant had been informed of the selection criteria (impact on strengthening democracy, the rule of law and respect for human rights in the country), having received the general conditions governing the budget heading B7-7 0 2 0 and having completed the standard form attached to them.
The Commission stated however that, in view of the large number of funding applications received (over 300 a year, only 20 % of which can be met), it was difficult to give a detailed explanation for each refusal.
In the present case, the Commission stated that the project was primarily socially and medically oriented (psychological care of children), and therefore not covered by the direct priorities of the budget line. The rejection decision was thus rather based on the nature of the project.
The complainant admitted having received the general conditions governing the budget heading. However, he observed that those conditions were very extensive and subject to interpretation. He also stated that he was still missing a clear argumentation of why his project did not fit exactly into the selection criteria.
The Decision
The alleged failure to state reasons for the rejection decision
1.1. The complainant alleged that the decision of 3 December 1996 by which the Commission rejected his funding application was unclear and failed to state sufficient reasons. The Commission observed that it had informed the complainant about the selection criteria and that only projects which contributed to the democratic development of the country could be funded. In its additional comments, the Commission stated that, in view of the large number of applications, it was difficult to give a detailed explanation for each refusal.
1.2. According to the case-law of the Court of Justice, the reasoning followed by the authority which adopted the measure must be disclosed in a clear and unequivocal fashion so as, on the one hand, to make the persons concerned aware of the reasons for the measure and thereby enable them to defend their rights, and, on the other, to enable the Court to exercise its supervisory jurisdiction(118).
1.3. By its letter of 3 December 1996, the Commission rejected the application in the following terms: