In November 1997, Mr G., director of a non-governmental organisation offering medical care to seriously injured children from war and crisis areas, complained to the Ombudsman about the rejection of his application for funding by DG VIII (Development) of the Commission. The project concerned was intended to integrate homeless children into selected new families, given that orphanages would not give them the family structure necessary for their emotional development. The project had been conceived by AAD (Angolan action for development, Luanda) and approved by the relevant Angolan Ministry. However, given the absence of adequate financial resources, on 30 August 1996 the complainant made an application to DG VIII for funding the project under the budget heading B7-7 0 2 0 (Promotion of human rights and democracy in the developing countries).
On 3 December 1996, the complainant was informed that his application had been rejected because of the limited resources of budget line B7-7 0 2 0 and because his project did not fit exactly into the criteria of the budget line. DG VIII equally informed the complainant that it doubted that the new families which already faced enormous daily problems could be the ideal home for these vulnerable children.
Finding the rejection decision unclear and not sufficiently motivated, the complainant wrote four times between December 1996 and September 1997 to the Commission asking for more explanations for the rejection of his application, in order to eventually reformulate the concept of the project. He received no reply until November 1997 when, further to a telephone request from the Ombudsman's office, the Commission answered his correspondence. However, the complainant was still unsatisfied with the reasoning of the rejection decision, which he considered contradictory, not objective and not clear enough. He therefore complained to the Ombudsman alleging that the Commission had failed:
to give him adequate reasons for the rejection decision, and
to reply during several months to his correspondence.
The inquiry
The Commission's opinion