1.2. In its first letter to the complainant, the selection board gave as the reasons for rejecting his candidature either the fact that he lacked a medical qualification or that he had failed to provide proof of studies in the field of occupational medicine (ett utbildningsbevis efter specialstudier i arbetsmedicin). In its second letter, the selection board gave a different reason: that he lacked sufficient experience compared with the other candidates in both the tropical medicine and the radiation safety fields.
1.3. It is a fundamental principle of good administrative behaviour that decisions should be reasoned, as required for example, by Article 190 of the EC Treaty. The reasoning should enable the affected party to know why a particular measure has been taken. In its comments to the Ombudsman, the Commission recognised that the selection board's first letter to the complainant was not absolutely clear on the motivation for this decision. In fact, it appears that the reasoning was not only unclear, but also wrong.
1.4. In its second letter, the selection board considered the complainant's experience insufficient compared with other candidates in both the tropical medicine and the radiation safety fields.
1.5. Article 27 of the Staff Regulations of the European Communities provides that recruitment shall be directed to securing for the institution the services of officials of the highest standard of ability and efficiency. In applying the criteria laid down in the notice of competition, the selection board was entitled to make a comparative evaluation of the candidates in order to ensure that the most suitable candidates were chosen for interview.
1.6. Taken by themselves, the reasons given in the second letter appeared adequate to enable the candidate to understand the reasons for his rejection. Furthermore the reasons were consistent with the proper exercise of judgement by the selection board. However, the second letter did not acknowledge that the reasons given in the first letter were wrong. Taken together therefore, the first and second letters were inadequate to explain the reasons for the candidate's rejection.
Alleged discrimination against candidates with Swedish medical qualifications