In his complaint to the Ombudsman X. claimed that:
his qualifications met the requirements for the open competition. In particular, he emphasised that he did have professional experience in the field of radiation safety and that this was not taken into account;
the Commission had given two different reasons for rejecting his application and that he had not therefore received an appropriate answer to his request for reconsideration of his case;
the Commission's faulty reasoning could indicate discrimination against candidates with Swedish medical qualifications.
The inquiry
The Commission's opinion
The complaint was forwarded to the Commission. In summary, the Commission's opinion made the following points.
The selection board examined the complainant's application form and decided not to admit him to the competition because it considered that he did not possess a diploma in occupational health medicine.
"The decision was notified to X. by a letter dated 29 May 1996. The board recognised that the letter was not absolutely clear on the motivation for this decision".
On request, the slection board re-examined the complainant's application and came to the conclusion that he did not have sufficient experience compared with the other candidates, neither in tropical medicine nor in radiation safety.
"The board can assure [X.] that its decision was not influenced by the timing of his studies in the Swedish education system but only by the need to ensure that only the most qualified candidates were invited to the interview".
The complainant's observations
In his observations, the complainant claimed that the Commission's explanations were still not entirely clear. He also pointed out that the Commission admitted that it had given two different reasons.
Finally, X. expressed his satisfaction about the board's assurance that its decision was not influenced by the timing of his studies in the Swedish education system.
The Decision
The Selection Board's reasoning
1.1. Competition COM/A/972 was organised to constitute a reserve list of grade A 5/A 4 medical advisers on occupational health in the Commission's Medical Service. Point III.B.2 of the notice of competition required candidates to be holders of a higher university degree in medicine and a certificate of specialised occupational health studies. Furthermore, candidates were required to have professional experience of, among other things, tropical medicine and radiation safety.