, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

2.1. In its opinion, the Commission stated that its decision was not influenced by the timing of the complainant's studies in the Swedish education system but only by the need to ensure that only the most qualified candidates were invited to the interview. In his observations the complainant expressed satisfaction with this response.

2.2. The Ombudsman's inquiries therefore revealed no evidence of maladministration in relation to this aspect of the complaint.

On the basis of the Ombudsman's inquiries into this complaint, it appeared necessary to make the following critical remarks:

It is a fundamental principle of good administrative behaviour that decisions should be reasoned, as required for example, by Article 190 of the EC Treaty. The reasoning should enable the affected party to know why a particular measure has been taken. In its comments to the Ombudsman, the Commission recognised that the selection board's first letter to the complainant "was not absolutely clear on the motivation for this decision". In fact, it appeared that the reasoning was not only unclear, but also wrong.

Taken by themselves, the reasons given in the second letter appeared adequate to enable the candidate to understand the reasons for his rejection. Furthermore the reasons were consistent with the proper exercise of judgment by the selection board. However, the second letter did not acknowledge that reasons given in the first letter were wrong. Taken together therefore, the first and second letters were inadequate to explain the reasons for the candidate's rejection.

Given that this aspect of the case concerned procedures relating to specific events in the past, it was not appropriate to pursue a friendly solution in the matter. The Ombudsman therefore closed the case.

MODIFICATION OF GRANTS FOR RESEARCH

Decision on complaints 878/13.9.96/TT/IT/PD and 905/26.9.96/AGS/IT/PD against the European Commission

The complaint

In September 1996, the Grant Holders Association complained to the Ombudsman about a reduction in the grants which its members received from the Commission and about the way in which the Commision had made the reduction.