, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force
609.

More generally, a merger that is found to give rise to significant impediment of effective competition may be found compatible with the internal market if it can be proved that without the merger the competition would be deteriorated at least to the same extent as the failing firm would simply disappear from the market. [260] In that context, "the Commission may decide that an otherwise problematic merger is nevertheless compatible with the common market if one of the merging parties is a failing firm. The basic requirement is that the deterioration of the competitive structure that follows the merger cannot be said to be caused by the merger. This will arise where the competitive structure of the market would deteriorate to at least the same extent in the absence of the merger." [261]

610.

It is then for the notifying Parties to provide in due time all the relevant information necessary to demonstrate that the deterioration of the competitive structure that follows the merger is not caused by the merger. [262]

611.

Lufthansa considers that bmi meets the requirements of the failing firm defence as set out in paras. 89-91 of the Commission’s Horizontal Merger Guidelines [263] :

i.

bmi is a separate entity rather than a division of Lufthansa.

ii.

bmi is a failing firm that, absent the Transaction, would in the near future be forced out of the market.

iii. There is no alternative purchaser for bmi.

iv. In the absence of the Transaction, bmi’s assets would inevitably exit the relevant markets.

1.

Firm vs. division

612.

Firstly, even if bmi has operated as a separate legal entity with its own management, brand, and commercial strategy since Lufthansa's takeover in 2009 [264] , bmi is a fully owned subsidiary of Lufthansa. The Lufthansa group is not facing overall financial difficulties; the losses incurred by bmi are not of a magnitude which would endanger the whole Lufthansa group (net loss of approximately EUR 170 million in 2010 and 2011, compared to total assets of EUR 29.3 billion, net profit of EUR 1.13 bn and cash flow from operating activities of EUR 3.1 bn for the overall Lufthansa group according to its 2010 consolidated statements).