, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force
40.

A majority of the competitors that responded classify passengers on the basis of their willingness to pay. The willingness to pay is identified on the basis of, amongst others, the time of booking, flexibility requirements, services at the airport, cabin comfort, length of stay, priority check-in, length of stay and whether or not there is a weekend between the dates of arrival and departure. In addition to the class of travel, time sensitive passengers are indeed identified by means of other criteria such as a booking date close to the day of travel, a same day return flight, flexible fares, sales distribution through corporate accounts, airport location, frequency of schedule and the use of frequent flyer programmes. A large majority of the competitors that responded confirmed their ability to discriminate (i.e. charge different prices) between the various categories of passengers and to apply yield management techniques.

41.

In terms of passenger preferences, the market investigation showed considerable differences between TS and NTS passengers: for example the existence of daily frequencies, timing of departure and return flights, airport location and ticket flexibility were generally considered very important for TS passengers, while these were considered to be less important for NTS passengers. Also, the possibility of a same day return was generally considered important for TS passengers, while not for NTS passengers.

42.

In light of the above, the effects of the Transaction will be assessed on the narrowest possible markets, namely on a market for TS passengers and on a market for NTS passengers. [21]

1.1.3. Airport substitutability

43.

When defining the relevant O&D markets for air transport services, the Commission previously found that flights from or to airports which have sufficiently overlapping catchment areas can be considered as substitutes in the eyes of passengers. In order to correctly capture the competitive constraint that flights from/to two different airports exert on each other, a detailed analysis taking into consideration the specific characteristics of the case at hand is necessary. [22] In the present case, airport substitutability is particularly relevant for London, Moscow and Vienna. [23]

1.1.3. (1) London

44.

London has five main airports [24] , namely Heathrow, Gatwick, City, Stansted and Luton. The travel distances and times between these airports and the centre of London are summarised in Table 1: