IAG has the right to remove the Chairman and CEO of IB Opco. Where a new Chairman or CEO is to be appointed, an ad hoc nominations committee is put in place. This committee consists of persons selected by IAG amongst the existing directors of IAG, BA and Iberia. IAG must select at least one member amongst the directors appointed by the Spanish Nationality Entity but is not constrained as regards the number of members on the committee.
The committee will nominate a person for the role (Chairman or CEO as the case may be). While the Spanish Nationality Entity has a formal right of veto over any person so nominated as Chairman or CEO, if it were to do so then IAG may arrange for the nominations committee to nominate another person in accordance with the same procedures or IAG may refer the matter to its own shareholders. [11] In the event of a vote by IAG shareholders on such an appointment, the voting rights of IAG shareholders who are Spanish nationals would be magnified so that they represent a majority of the total voting rights in IAG in relation to that matter. In case of such a dispute between IAG and the Spanish Nationality Entity, should IAG refer the matter to its shareholders, the decision taken by IAG shareholders according to the above-mentioned procedure would be binding. Should the person proposed by the nominations committee be approved by IAG shareholders, that person would be appointed.
From the above it is concluded that the criteria of Article 5(4)(b)(iii) of the Merger Regulation are satisfied and the turnover of Iberia should be added to that of IAG because IAG has the power to appoint more than half of the directors of Iberia. It is immaterial at which level of IAG the ultimate decision is taken, or how the voting rights of IAG’s shareholders are weighted in case of a vote, what matters is that IAG has the power to appoint seven of the eleven directors.
In subordinate order it is also noted that IAG has the right to manage the affairs of IB Opco Holding in the sense of Article 5(4)(iv) of the Merger Regulation and also de facto has the power to exercise more than half of the voting rights in the sense of Article 5(4)(ii) of the Merger Regulation.
1.1.2. (2) IAG has the right to manage IB Opco's affairs (Article 5(4)(b)(iv) of the Merger Regulation)