The quickest journey time for travel by train [144] between London and Edinburgh is 240-262 min by direct train [145] and 291 – 310 min by indirect train [146] and 156 min at minimum by plane from Heathrow. IAG considers however that the air travel time indication is in practice underestimated because it excludes certain elements such as waiting time for Heathrow Express. [147] If East Coast trains' direct services are included in the relevant market, the market shares of the Parties and their competitors on the all-passenger market would be as follows: [148]
Table 10 London-Edinburgh market shares including train travel
2009 annual pax |Number of passengers |% share |
IAG |[900,000-950,000] |[20-30]% |
bmi |[300,000-350,000] |[10-20]% |
Combined |[1,200,000-1,250,000] |[30-40]% |
Air France |[150,000-200,000] |[5-10]% |
easyJet |[950,000-1,000,000] |[30-40]% |
East Coast trains |[750,000-800,000] |[20-30]% |
TOTAL |[3,150,000-3,200,000] |100% |
Source: Form CO based on CAA and MIDT data and National Rail Trends 2009-2010 Yearbook
The market shares in Table 10 above comprise train services between London and Edinburgh and air services between London(five) and Edinburgh. [149] If, however train services were to be included in the same market as air services between London(three) and Edinburgh, the Parties estimate that their combined market share would be [50-60]% with train having a market share of [30-40]%. On a market limited to train services and air services between Heathrow and Edinburgh, IAG estimates that the combined market shares would be [50-60]% with train having the other [50-60]% of the market.
The Parties were not able to provide TS and NTS passenger market share data. East Coast Mainline Company (East Coast trains) also submitted that they do not consider it possible to distinguish between passengers. The information provided by East Coast trains during the market investigation was based on the assumption that the majority of their customers are NTS
1.4.2. (2) TS passengers
Competition from air services
Assuming that the relevant market comprises only air services, the Parties' market shares vary significantly depending on which airports in the London area are taken into consideration in the relevant market.
In particular, if only Heathrow is included, the Transaction leads to a monopoly with an increment of [20-30]%, based on the Summer 2011 IATA season data.