, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force

Table 17 Overview of frequency of air services on the London-Nice route

Carrier |Summer 2011 |Winter 2010 |

|Daily |Weekly |Daily |Weekly |

LON-NCE |

IAG |8 |59 |6 |40 |

bmi |0 |2 |- |- |

Combined |8 |61 |6 |40 |

easyJet |7 |48 |3 |22 |

Total |15 |109 |9 |62 |

LHR/LGW/LCY-NCE |

IAG |8 |59 |6 |40 |

bmi |0 |2 |- |- |

Combined |8 |61 |6 |40 |

easyJet |4 |27 |2 |13 |

Total |12 |88 |8 |53 |

LHR-NCE |

IAG |7 |51 |5 |35 |

bmi |0 |2 |- |- |

Combined |7 |53 |5 |35 |

easyJet |- |- |- |- |

Total |7 |53 |5 |35 |

Source: Form CO

1.4.5. (2) TS passengers

281.

Even though on the basis of the data indicated in the tables above it might seem that the Transaction would only bring about a small increment, it must be noted that the above data are not representative of bmi's real market power, since bmi only recently started operating on the route. Furthermore, bmi has been able to quickly increase its weekly frequencies from 2 in Summer 2011 to already 11 in Winter 2011-2012.

282.

The Parties' market shares with respect to the TS passenger segment vary depending on which London airports are taken into consideration in the relevant market. In particular, on a Heathrow-Nice route, the Transaction would lead to a monopoly. On a London(three)-Nice market, which would also include flights offered by easyJet from Gatwick, the Transaction would lead the merged entity with respect to the TS passenger segment to a [60-70]% market share based on the Summer 2011 IATA season data (easyJet [30-40]%). On an even wider London(five)-Nice market, the Transaction would lead the merged entity to a market share of [40-50]% with respect to the TS passenger segment based on the Summer 2011 IATA season data ( easyJet [50-60]%).

283.

Moreover, bmi exited the Heathrow-Nice route in October 2007 and re-entered in August 2011. Using these events in a quantitative analysis, it appears that after controlling for seasonality and costs, bmi's exit and re-entry on the Heathrow to Nice route had a big effect on IAG's prices. Therefore, bmi would be a significant constraint on IAG's price setting on the route.